Where does our love for AI end begin?

Published: Do you still remember when you first saw it, and you were like, "Wow, this text is amazing"? And then your love began to fade. Was it "And honestly"? Or maybe em dashes? The more you use it, the quicker you spot it. It's everywhere, so you just skip it. It started with text, then with fast food menus, then it crept into web design. So I wonder where does our love for AI end? Or begin? I've been thinking writing…

To confront my bias, I use AI daily. It's an exciting time to be building and I often joke I fell in love with coding twice.

People have different opinions about AI. We have haters, skeptics, and optimistis (mostly LinkedIn creeps). Even though I'm in the latter group (minus LinkedIn), there are AI use cases I despise and I'm often unsure how others – that is, people who don't speak to 6 agents in parallel for 8 hours a day – feel about them.

In this short essay, I'll go through 6 areas where AI is used… but should it be?

Contents

  1. AI is cheating!
  2. AI ads for (fast-food) restaurant
  3. AI in writing
  4. GenAI photos
  5. Visual design
  6. Agentic coding

1). Chess is a total no-go

It's been 30 years since AI beat Garry Kasparov, the reigning world chess champion. But obviously, using AI in chess games is strictly prohibited and, quite rightfully, considered cheating. No one would play chess with you if you were using AI.

So, on a scale of 1 to 5, chess – and other games – are a 0.

2). AI ads for (fast-food) restaurant

AI-generated cabbage rolls with sour cream and polenta in a ceramic dish.
AI sarma. Source: Easy-Peasy.AI.
A pavement menu board advertising coffee, juices, and desserts with glossy food illustrations.
AI menu. Source: u/shubhamxtreme on Reddit.

Now, there was a time when someone saw an AI-generated menu and said, "Wow, that looks great, let's use it for our restaurant". You know what I'm talking about.

I'm ashamed to admit that I went to one of those places to order sarma. The ad that lured me in showed 10 rolls of sarma, cowered with delicious warm sauce, served in a clay pot.
I got 3, served on a plastic plate with 2 salad leaves. I used my tears to salt the meal.

However, the use of AI in restaurants isn't as bad as in our previous example (chess).
There's value in knowing which restaurants to ignore.

Therefore, I give it 1 out of 5.

3). AI in writing

This used to be everywhere, but I have a feeling that it's either

  1. dying out, or
  2. getting better so we can't spot it easily.

People used bots to auto-reply to comments (looking at you, LinkedIn creeps), which quickly became too cringe, even for LinkedIn. AI slop was in most second-tier marketing comms, and some people used it on their blogs and email. Those who work in tech and write a lot have developed a good radar and a huge disdain for it (think late 90s banner blindness).

Now, funny thing is… I recently saw AI-generated copy for kids' brain development workshop ad, which pissed me off more than I care to admit. (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻
People who are supposed to teach kids how to use brain are offloading their cognitive tasks to an agent. So I've asked 3 people what they think of (the ad). Some fairly educated people, including a doctor who used to work at a Mayo Clinic.
And to my surprise, they did not notice it.

I feel this gets a 2 out of 5.
Acceptable, if you use it sensibly and on a smaller scale, but a no-go if it's fully AI-written slop.

4). Photography

AI-generated photos are flooding communities, and it's already impossible to tell if a photo is a "photo" or an "AI-photo". Henri Cartier-Bresson, one of the most famous photographers, once said:

If you start cutting or cropping a good photograph, it means death to the geometrically correct interplay of proportions.
– Henri in The Decisive Moment, 1952.

In other words, the dude was against cropping! All photo editing software has an option to crop these days (or since its inception) and new releases of Photoshop or Apple Photos even have "reverse cropping" – in Apple Photos, this feature is called "Extend", where AI contextually enlarges your photo.

So, why do we care how a photo was made? I look at photos similarly to how I look at art, and if a photo invokes certain feelings, does it really matter? Paintings were never real, yet that has never bothered us. GenAI enabled people with motion disabilities to dictate an AI to generate a photo in places they were never going to travel to. It has given people more freedom to express themselves.

I suspect that non AI-gen photos will only retain value in photo journalism.

Or not? Let's do a quick experiment in 3 photos, and you can decide on your own.

Three posts with the same black-and-white monkey on a rope bridge: a story about a difficult expedition receives 188k likes and 187 reshares; a zoo caption receives 13 likes; an AI-generated caption receives 2 likes.

So, which of these would get your like?

My take here is 3 out of 5.
Use it if you have to.

5). Visual design & after effects

I recently stumbled upon Voyager, a harness for creative software (think Photoshop, Blender, Unity, DaVinci Resolve…). Their tagline is "Your taste. Your vision." Nice, I quite like it. Also, remember Claude Design? People do and some are fatigued by it:

Complains about Claude's (lack of?) design taste on LinkedIn

Design is a tricky task to be automated. If you don't care or you haven't developed taste, you're gonna offload this task to Claude thinking your work is great and you'll move on. Lately, as I've been stumbling upon way too obiously AI-generated web-designs, and I've just had to close the tab immediately and clean my eyes with Holy water.

On the other end of a spectrum are people who care about the design, and they can now make great things much faster. They can skip the work that once felt like "an errand" to get what they want. And repeat it over and over again.

So, on a scale from 1 to 5… it's between 4 and 5.

  • 4, because… sooo many websites now look the same now.
  • 5, otherwise.

6). Software; agentic coding

All-in! And it's not even a debate.

Not just for crunching out the same old features faster, but also building things we weren't able to build before.

Do people who use software care if code is AI-generated or not? No! And since no one is writting code by hand anymore, it doesn't seem they have a choice.

It's 5/5.
No one writes code by hand anymore, and no one cares.


🤖: Do you want me to generate an outro for you, or are you fine to leave it as is?
Just kiddin'. There's no outro.

blog comments powered by Disqus